
On the surface, this seems like it makes sense. If you had a 2-foot diameter water pipe vs. a 1-foot diameter pipe, the 2 foot one is going to let more water through. But light is a weird thing, and there’s more going on inside your rifle scope than you may think.
The actual benefit of a larger maintube is more adjustment travel – plain and simple. The erector system (the part inside the scope that controls magnification and point-of-impact) moves around inside the maintube. With long-range shots, the bullet drops more the farther you shoot. Adjusting your elevation dial allows you to compensate for this bullet drop. The larger the maintube, the more adjustment you can dial into your elevation, which compensates for larger drops at farther distances.
The little-known fact is that it’s the erector system that limits how much light is getting to your eye. It also has a big effect on image quality.
Here’s a scenario that you may have run across – you have two different scopes from two different brands with similar specs. Both have the same magnification range, maintube diameter, and objective lens size. But brand A has 20 MOA less travel than brand B. How is that possible? Well you can’t cheat physics, so instead, some companies decrease the diameter of the erector system, thus providing you with more travel. Of course, the downside is that this also decrease the amount of light and the quality of the image that’s getting to your eye.
That’s why we didn’t skimp on the Mark 5HD’s maintube size. We decided to go with a 35mm maintube, so we could have the right amount of travel, while still preserving an incredibly bright and clear image with a larger diameter erector system.